Objects & Modifiers

Adverbial Objectives & Retained Objects

A noun that looks like a direct object but is really answering how long? or how far? — and what happens to an object when a sentence is turned around into the passive.

What you’ll learn

  • Spot a noun doing an adverb's job
  • Test whether a noun after a verb is really a direct object
  • Understand what happens to the second object of a passive verb
  • Recognise the expletive 'there'

Nouns doing an adverb’s job

The lecture lasted an hour.an hour sits exactly where a direct object would, but nothing was done to it. It answers how long?, which is an adverb’s question.

That is an adverbial objective: a noun phrase functioning as an adverb. Because its job is adverbial, it is diagrammed like an adverb — below the verb, not on the base line.

  1. Try the passive test

    A real direct object can become the subject of a passive sentence. An hour was lasted by the lecture is nonsense, so an hour is not a direct object.
  2. Ask which question it answers

    How long? How far? How often? When? — all adverb questions. A direct object answers what? or whom?
  3. Diagram it below the verb

    On a horizontal beneath the verb, like an indirect object but answering a different question.

The lecture lasted an hour.

lecturelastedThehouran
Reed-Kellogg — below the verb, where adverbs live
detnsubjROOTdetnpadvmodThelecturelastedanhour
  • detDeterminer
  • nsubjNominal subject
  • ROOTRoot of the sentence
  • npadvmodNoun phrase as adverbial modifier
Dependency — npadvmod, not dobj

Comparing the two views

Both notations agree that this is not a direct object, and both say so explicitly. Reed-Kellogg moves it off the base line entirely. The dependency parse keeps it in place but labels it npadvmod — literally “noun phrase as adverbial modifier” — rather than dobj. This is a case where reading the relation label saves you from a wrong analysis.

Retained objects

When a verb with two objects goes passive, only one of them can become the subject. The other stays put — it is retained.

Grandma sent Luis a postcardLuis was sent a postcard. Luis is now the subject, but a postcard is still sitting after the verb with nowhere to go. Diagram it in the direct-object slot, exactly where it was.

The expletive there

In There were three owls in the barn., there is not a place. It is a placeholder holding the subject position open while the real subject — three owls — waits until after the verb.

Diagram the real subject in the subject slot, and put there on a short line above it, since it is filling a slot rather than meaning anything.

There were three owls in the barn.

Thereowlswerethreeinbarnthe
Reed-Kellogg — the real subject moves into the subject slot
explROOTnummodattrprepdetpobjTherewerethreeowlsinthebarn
  • explExpletive
  • ROOTRoot of the sentence
  • nummodNumeric modifier
  • attrAttribute
  • prepPrepositional modifier
  • detDeterminer
  • pobjObject of preposition
Dependency — expl marks the placeholder

Comparing the two views

Reed-Kellogg reorganises the sentence to show the grammar: owls goes into the subject slot even though it appears third. The dependency tree leaves the words alone and marks There with the dedicated relation expl “expletive” in the technical sense of a semantically empty placeholder. Once again the diagram rearranges and the tree relabels.

Key terms

Adverbial objective
A noun phrase answering an adverb’s question. Relation npadvmod, drawn below the verb. We waited an hour. She walked home.

See: Adverbs

Retained object
The object left behind when a two-object verb goes passive and the other object becomes the subject. She was given a medal.medal stays an object. We were told the truth.

See: Indirect Objects & Complements

Expletive
A word filling a grammatical slot without contributing meaning. There as a placeholder subject is the standard case; relation expl. There is a bird in the yard. There were no seats left.

See: Function Word Relations

Practice on a real sentence

Watch for a noun phrase that is not a direct object.

This store is as large as that one.

Parts of speech

Give every word its coarse Universal Dependencies category.

Words 0/8Attempts 0Correct 0Time 0:00

Sentence — select a part of speech below, then click the word(s) it applies to

This store is as large as that one.