Dependency Relations
Core Arguments
What you’ll learn
- Use the deletion test to tell a core argument from a modifier
- Tell the subject relations (nsubj, nsubjpass, csubj) from the object relations (dobj, dative)
- Choose between attr, acomp and oprd for a complement
- Label a recipient: dative before the direct object, pobj after to
- Tell ccomp from xcomp by asking whether the inner clause has its own subject
- Tell pobj from pcomp, and find the agent in a passive sentence
Required or optional: the deletion test
The quickest check is the deletion test. Marta repaired the radio quietly still works without quietly: it just tells you less. Without the radio, it does not work: Marta repaired sounds unfinished. So quietly is a modifier, and the radio is a core argument.
The test is a guide, not a rule. Some verbs can drop their object: She paints. Other members of this family can often be left out too, such as the recipient (dative) and the by phrase that names the doer in a passive sentence (agent on by, pobj on the doer): The waiter brought coffee. The mural was painted. They still count as core arguments because the verb implies them: bring implies someone who receives, and a passive verb implies someone who did the action.
All thirteen are drawn in the same colour: the colour names the relation family, and the label names the exact relation. So two arcs of this colour in one tree, such as nsubj and dobj, are two different relations from the same family.
Subjects
nsubj Nominal subject
A noun or pronoun acting as the subject of a verb. Its head is the verb. It is usually the easiest relation to find in a tree: find the root first, then ask who or what is doing the action.
How the parser decides: the noun or pronoun that agrees with the verb. In a statement it comes before the verb. The label goes on the noun, never on the determiner in front of it.
“The lantern flickered twice.”
- det Determiner
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- advmod Adverbial modifier
“She paints enormous murals.”
A sentence can carry several. An embedded clause has a subject of its own, and it is also nsubj, but its head is the embedded verb, not the root.
“She hopes the rain stops.”
nsubjpass Passive nominal subject
The subject of a passive verb — grammatically the subject, but semantically the thing the action happened to. The bridge did not rebuild anything.
How the parser decides: the subject of a verb that also has an auxpass child. The two labels come as a pair: if you find one, look for the other on the same verb.
“The bridge was rebuilt.”
- det Determiner
- nsubjpass Passive nominal subject
- auxpass Passive auxiliary
- ROOT Root of the sentence
“Our tickets were refunded quickly.”
csubj Clausal subject
A whole clause serving as the subject. The label goes on the verb of that inner clause, which is what makes it look strange at first — the arc runs verb-to-verb.
How the parser decides: the root has no nominal subject of its own, and a subordinate verb occupies the slot where one would be. Rare in ordinary prose.
“Whoever wins gets the prize.”
- nsubj Nominal subject
- csubj Clausal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- det Determiner
- dobj Direct object
“Whatever remains belongs to you.”
Objects
dobj Direct object
The direct object: the thing the verb acts on. Its head is the verb, and unlike a subject it normally follows.
How the parser decides: a noun or pronoun after the verb, with no preposition in front of it, that is not the indirect object. When the verb has two objects, as in brought us coffee, the second one is the dobj.
“Marta repaired the radio.”
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- det Determiner
- dobj Direct object
“The waiter brought us coffee.”
“The noise startled him.”
dative Dative
The indirect object: the person or thing that receives something. It gets this label when it comes right after the verb, before the direct object, with no preposition in front of it.
How the parser decides: mostly by position. In gave Nora the keys, two nouns follow the verb, and the first one, Nora, is the dative.
“Rafael gave Nora the keys.”
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- dative Dative
- det Determiner
- dobj Direct object
“Rafael handed the keys to Nora.”
Complements
Five labels compete for the slot after a verb, and choosing between them is the hardest part of this family. Ask these questions in order:
- Is it a whole clause, with a verb of its own? It is
ccompif the clause has its own subject (said the ferry sank),xcompif it borrows the main subject (wants to learn). - Does it rename or describe the subject? A noun is
attr(was a stranger), an adjectiveacomp(felt slippery). After seem, appear and a few other verbs, this parser usually usesoprdfor both. - Does it rename or describe the direct object? It is usually
oprd(elected him treasurer).
attr Attribute
A noun after a linking verb that renames the subject — the traditional predicate nominative. The winner and a stranger are the same person.
How the parser decides: a noun complement of a linking verb. The linking verb (here was) is the root, and the complement hangs from it. The parser never uses the separate cop label.
“The winner was a stranger.”
- det Determiner
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- attr Attribute
“This is my final offer.”
acomp Adjectival complement
An adjective after a linking verb, describing the subject. It fills the same slot as attr; the difference is the part of speech of the complement.
How the parser decides: an adjectival complement of a verb. Comparatives behave identically to plain adjectives here.
“The pavement felt slippery.”
- det Determiner
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- acomp Adjectival complement
“The room grew darker.”
oprd Object predicate
An object predicate: a word describing the direct object rather than the subject. In elected him treasurer, treasurer is what him became.
How the parser decides: the label covers two different constructions. In one, the word follows a direct object and renames or describes it (elected him treasurer). In the other, there is no object at all: the word usually follows seem or appear and describes the subject (seems conclusive).
“The class elected him treasurer.”
- det Determiner
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- dobj Direct object
- oprd Object predicate
“The evidence seems conclusive.”
ccomp Clausal complement
A clausal complement with its own subject — a whole clause functioning as the object of a verb, often a verb of saying, thinking or asking.
How the parser decides: the complement clause has a subject that is not shared with the outer verb. This is the one distinction that separates it from xcomp.
“He said the ferry sank.”
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- det Determiner
- ccomp Clausal complement
“She asked whether anyone objected.”
xcomp Open clausal complement
An open clausal complement — one whose subject is missing and understood to be the outer clause’s. In Ravi wants to learn, the learner is Ravi, but nothing in the inner clause says so.
How the parser decides: a complement clause with no subject of its own. “Open” means exactly that gap.
“Ravi wants to learn Portuguese.”
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- aux Auxiliary
- xcomp Open clausal complement
- dobj Direct object
“He seems to understand.”
So a to-infinitive is not always an xcomp. In Omar wants his sister to drive, sister is the nsubj of drive. The infinitive has its own subject, so drive is a ccomp. Spanish speakers often write Omar wants that his sister drives ✗, from quiere que su hermana maneje. That is not correct English: after want, English uses the person and then a to-infinitive.
“Omar wants his sister to drive.”
Arguments of a preposition
pobj Object of preposition
The object of a preposition. Its head is always the preposition itself, never the verb or noun that the whole phrase modifies. That is why a prepositional phrase takes two arcs, not one.
The label sits on one word, the head noun: sofa, not the sofa. The phrase that word heads — it plus everything hanging below it — is what the Roles exercise boxes as the object of the preposition. The same holds for every relation on this page: nsubj marks keys, and the subject is The keys.
How the parser decides: the noun or pronoun that a prep introduces. It is one of the most common relations, and it always hangs from its preposition.
“The keys fell behind the sofa.”
- det Determiner
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- prep Prepositional modifier
- pobj Object of preposition
“The road to Cusco reopened.”
pcomp Complement of preposition
What a preposition takes when its object is a verb form rather than a noun. Most often this is an -ing form, a gerund. It can also be the verb of a clause: in thought about what he said, said is the pcomp of about.
How the parser decides: the complement of a preposition is verbal. Compare insisted on the delay (pobj) with insisted on leaving (pcomp).
“She insisted on leaving early.”
- nsubj Nominal subject
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- prep Prepositional modifier
- pcomp Complement of preposition
- advmod Adverbial modifier
“They apologised for arriving late.”
agent Agent (passive)
The word by in a passive sentence. It usually introduces the doer, the person or thing that performed the action. It is a preposition with a label of its own: agent sits on by itself, and the noun below it is an ordinary pobj.
How the parser decides: by attached to a passive verb, even when it does not name a doer. In The car was parked by the door, by names a place, but the verb is passive, so by is still the agent. After an active verb, a by that names a place is a plain prep: she waited by the door.
Every word that takes agent
- by, and nothing else. The doer itself is the
pobjunder it.
“The mural was painted by students.”
- det Determiner
- nsubjpass Passive nominal subject
- auxpass Passive auxiliary
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- agent Agent (passive)
- pobj Object of preposition
“The letter was signed by the mayor.”
- det Determiner
- nsubjpass Passive nominal subject
- auxpass Passive auxiliary
- ROOT Root of the sentence
- agent Agent (passive)
- pobj Object of preposition
Quick check
- Which word is the
dativein Nina sent Omar a message? And what label does Omar get in Nina sent a message to Omar?Answer
Omar is thedativein the first sentence: it receives something, and it comes right after the verb, before the direct object message. In the second sentence, Omar is thepobjof to, because a preposition now stands in front of it. The to itself is labelleddativehere, as it nearly always is after send. - Which label does the last word get in each sentence? (a) The bread tastes fresh. (b) Their coach became a referee. (c) We named the boat Esperanza. (d) The task seemed difficult.
Answer
(a)acomp: fresh is an adjective describing the subject. (b)attr: referee is a noun renaming the subject. (c)oprd: Esperanza renames the direct object, the boat. (d)oprd, notacomp: after seem and appear, this parser usually labels the complementoprd, even though there is no object. - Is call a
ccompor anxcompin Santiago expects to call? And in Santiago expects his brother to call?Answer
In the first, call is anxcomp: it has no subject of its own, and the one who calls is Santiago, borrowed from the main clause. In the second, it is accomp. Here brother is thensubjof call, so the inner clause has its own subject. Being a to-infinitive does not make it anxcomp.
Key terms
- Core argument
- Something a verb or preposition needs, not just allows. Deleting it usually breaks the sentence instead of shortening it. Diego owns a bicycle. — drop a bicycle and the sentence breaks. She became a pilot.
See: Grammar Basics
- Complement
- A word or clause completing the meaning of a verb. Five labels share the slot:
attr,acomp,oprdand, for clauses,ccompandxcomp. She became a pilot. —attr. The road was icy. —acomp. - Open clause
- A subordinate clause with no subject of its own, borrowing one from the clause above. The reason
xcompis called an open clausal complement. She wants to leave. — she is understood as the one leaving. They began to sing. - Indirect object
- The recipient. Labelled
dativewhen it comes right after the verb, before the direct object. Rephrased with to, the recipient is apobj, and to itself is labelledprepordative. She handed Luis a postcard. —dative. She handed a postcard to Luis. —prep+pobj.
Practice on a real sentence
nsubj first. Then decide which noun after the verb is the recipient (dative) and which is the thing told (dobj): the recipient comes first. The words being interviewed describe one of those nouns, so they hang below it, not below the verb.Loading the practice sentence…