Dependency Relations

Modifier Relations

This page covers seven relations for optional detail: words, phrases and clauses that add information to another word. A core argument is required, but you can usually delete a modifier and still have a complete sentence. Three of the seven attach whole clauses, and they are the hardest to tell apart.

What you’ll learn

  • Apply the deletion test to tell a modifier from a core argument, and name where it fails
  • Find the word an advmod or prep attaches to: a verb, an adjective, an adverb or a noun
  • Tell neg from advmod, and npadvmod from dobj
  • Read a prepositional phrase as two arcs: prep on the preposition, pobj on its object
  • Choose between advcl, relcl and acl for a clause

The deletion test: most modifiers can be removed

Delete reluctantly from The engine started reluctantly, and The engine started is still a complete sentence. Now delete the object from Marta repaired the radio: Marta repaired is not complete. So the radio is a core argument, and reluctantly is a modifier.

This is the deletion test from Grammar Basics, where the optional parts of a sentence are called adjuncts. “Optional” is about grammar, not meaning. Not is a modifier, but deleting it reverses the meaning of the sentence.

Adverbial modifiers

advmod Adverbial modifier

An adverb that modifies another word. The label is the same whether the adverb modifies a verb, an adjective or another adverb, so the label alone does not tell you which. Sometimes the head is even a noun: in Only Priya answered, only attaches to Priya.

How the parser decides: the dependent is an adverb, and its head is the word it modifies. To read one, follow the arc up to its head.

“The engine started reluctantly.”

detnsubjROOTadvmodTheenginestartedreluctantly
  • det Determiner
  • nsubj Nominal subject
  • ROOT Root of the sentence
  • advmod Adverbial modifier
Modifying a verb — the ordinary case

“The soup was unusually salty.”

detnsubjROOTadvmodacompThesoupwasunusuallysalty
Modifying an adjective — 'unusually' attaches to 'salty', not to 'was'

“She spoke very softly.”

nsubjROOTadvmodadvmodShespokeverysoftly
Modifying another adverb — two advmod arcs, one stacked on the other

neg Negation modifier

A negative word: not, n’t, never, or the no of no longer. It has its own label, not advmod, because it does not add detail: it reverses the meaning.

How the parser decides: the word is one of these negators. It attaches to the word it negates, normally the main verb.

Every word that takes neg

  • not, n’t, never, and no before a comparative: no longer, no taller
  • Not neg: no before a noun (no bus) is det, and nor is cc. Nothing, nobody and none take the label of their job in the sentence, such as dobj.

“The tap does not work.”

detnsubjauxnegROOTThetapdoesnotwork
  • det Determiner
  • nsubj Nominal subject
  • aux Auxiliary
  • neg Negation modifier
  • ROOT Root of the sentence
The word 'not' attaches to the main verb, 'work', beside the auxiliary 'does'

“She never answers her phone.”

nsubjnegROOTpossdobjSheneveranswersherphone
The word 'never' is a negator, so it takes neg, not advmod

“I no longer live here.”

nsubjnegadvmodROOTadvmodInolongerlivehere
In 'no longer', 'no' is a negator too: it attaches to 'longer', and 'longer' to the verb

npadvmod Noun phrase as adverbial modifier

A noun phrase doing an adverb’s job, with no preposition in front of it. It says how long, how far or when: ran three hours. Add a preposition and the labels change: in ran for three hours, for is prep and hours is pobj.

How the parser decides: a noun phrase that modifies a verb or an adjective and answers an adverb’s question. It is the label for adverbial objectives. A one-word time noun such as tomorrow gets it too, although the Reed-Kellogg diagram draws that word as a plain adverb on a slant.

“The meeting ran three hours.”

detnsubjROOTnummodnpadvmodThemeetingranthreehours
  • det Determiner
  • nsubj Nominal subject
  • ROOT Root of the sentence
  • nummod Numeric modifier
  • npadvmod Noun phrase as adverbial modifier
The noun 'hours' says how long the meeting ran; the verb does not act on it

“We leave next Tuesday.”

nsubjROOTamodnpadvmodWeleavenextTuesday
A time expression with no preposition takes the same label

“My cousin is five years old.”

possnsubjROOTnummodnpadvmodacompMycousinisfiveyearsold
Modifying an adjective — 'years' attaches to 'old', not to the verb

prep Prepositional modifier

A preposition that modifies another word. The label sits on the preposition itself. Its object attaches to the preposition with a second arc, pobj, so a prepositional phrase is normally two arcs.

How the parser decides: the word is a preposition, and its head is the word the phrase modifies: a verb, a noun or an adjective. As with advmod, the label stays the same while the head changes, and the head is what changes the meaning.

Two exceptions. When the object is an -ing verb, the second arc is pcomp, not pobj: She left after finishing lunch. And a preposition at the end of a clause gets no pobj arc, because its object comes earlier in the sentence: This is the pen I write with.

“The fox slipped through the hedge.”

detnsubjROOTprepdetpobjThefoxslippedthroughthehedge
  • det Determiner
  • nsubj Nominal subject
  • ROOT Root of the sentence
  • prep Prepositional modifier
  • pobj Object of preposition
Attached to a verb — the phrase says where the fox went

“The path beside the canal flooded.”

detnsubjprepdetpobjROOTThepathbesidethecanalflooded
Attached to a noun — the phrase says which path

“She is fond of puzzles.”

nsubjROOTacomppreppobjSheisfondofpuzzles
Attached to an adjective — 'of' attaches to 'fond', which is the acomp of 'is'

Clausal modifiers

Three labels attach a whole clause as a modifier. A clause that modifies a verb is advcl. A clause that modifies a noun is relcl or acl, and the tip at the end of this section shows how to choose. A clause that a verb needs is not a modifier. In Omar said that the bus was late, Omar said is not complete, so the clause is a ccomp, a core argument.

advcl Adverbial clause modifier

An adverb clause: a whole clause that modifies a verb and says when, why, or under what condition. The label goes on the verb of the adverb clause, and its head is the word it modifies, usually a verb.

How the parser decides: a clause attached to a verb, not to a noun. It normally starts with a subordinating conjunction such as until, because or if, which takes the label mark.

Comparisons are the exception: a clause after than attaches to the adjective or adverb that it compares. In The lake was colder than it looked, looked is the advcl of colder, not of was (see what an adverb clause modifies).

“We waited until the rain stopped.”

nsubjROOTmarkdetnsubjadvclWewaiteduntiltherainstopped
  • nsubj Nominal subject
  • ROOT Root of the sentence
  • mark Marker
  • det Determiner
  • advcl Adverbial clause modifier
The verb 'stopped' is the advcl of 'waited', and 'until' is its mark

“If the alarm sounds, leave quickly.”

markdetnsubjadvclROOTadvmodIfthealarmsoundsleavequickly
The if-clause comes first, but 'sounds' still attaches to the main verb, 'leave'

relcl Relative clause modifier

A relative clause that modifies a noun. It starts with a relative pronoun (who, which, that) or with nothing at all. The parser uses the same label for a clause that starts with a relative adverb: the year when the bridge closed. Traditional grammar calls that an adjective clause, not a relative clause.

How the parser decides: a clause attached to a noun, where the noun also has a job inside the clause. The label sits on the clause’s verb, and its head is the noun: the arc runs from the noun down to the verb. An infinitive can be a relcl too: in We need something to eat, something is the object of eat. See Infinitives.

“The baker who trained me retired.”

detnsubjnsubjrelcldobjROOTThebakerwhotrainedmeretired
  • det Determiner
  • nsubj Nominal subject
  • relcl Relative clause modifier
  • dobj Direct object
  • ROOT Root of the sentence
The word 'who' is the subject of 'trained', and 'trained' is the relcl of 'baker'

“The song she wrote won awards.”

detnsubjnsubjrelclROOTdobjThesongshewrotewonawards
No relative pronoun at all — the relation is unchanged

acl Clausal modifier of noun

A clause that modifies a noun but is not a relative clause. Most are participial phrases or infinitive phrases: the man wearing a hat, her decision to resign. A that-clause after a noun such as fact or news takes acl too: They accepted the fact that prices rose.

How the parser decides: a participle after a noun normally takes acl. Any other clause takes acl when the noun has no job inside it. In the fact that prices rose, fact has no job inside the clause, so that is only a mark there, not a relative pronoun. The parser is not fully consistent: in Diego wrote a song to sing, sing gets acl, although song is its object.

“The man wearing a hat waved.”

detnsubjacldetdobjROOTThemanwearingahatwaved
  • det Determiner
  • nsubj Nominal subject
  • acl Clausal modifier of noun
  • dobj Direct object
  • ROOT Root of the sentence
A participial phrase — 'wearing' attaches to 'man'

“Her decision to resign surprised us.”

possnsubjauxaclROOTdobjHerdecisiontoresignsurprisedus
An adjectival infinitive phrase — 'to resign' says which decision

Quick check

  1. Delete on his bike from Omar relies on his bike. Is the rest a complete sentence? Which label does the parser give on?
    Answer
    No. Omar relies is not complete, because rely needs on and an object. The parser still labels on prep, with bike as its pobj: it does not separate required prepositional phrases from optional ones. The deletion test explains what a modifier is; the tree gives the label.
  2. In Nina ran five miles and Nina ran five races, one noun is npadvmod and the other is dobj. Which is which, and why?
    Answer
    miles is npadvmod: it answers how far?, and the running does not act on it. races is dobj: it answers what did Nina run? The verb is the same in both sentences, so the question the noun answers decides the label.
  3. Each sentence has a clause inside it. Which label does the bold verb get: advcl, relcl or acl? (a) The boy carrying the box tripped. (b) The soup that Nina made was cold. (c) We left before the film ended.
    Answer
    (a) acl: carrying is a participle with no subject of its own, and it modifies the noun boy. (b) relcl: the clause modifies soup, and soup has a job inside it: Nina made the soup. (c) advcl: the clause modifies the verb left and says when. Before is its mark.

Key terms

Modifier
Optional detail added to another word. Deleting it usually leaves a complete sentence; deleting a core argument does not. The tired birds slept. Birds sing at dawn.

See: Grammar Basics

Deletion test
Delete a word or phrase and check whether the rest is still a complete sentence. If it is, the part you deleted was usually a modifier. If it is not, the part was required, usually a core argument. The engine started reluctantly. — delete reluctantly and the sentence is still complete. Marta repaired the radio. — delete the radio and it is not.

See: Grammar Basics

Adverbial clause
Another name for an adverb clause: a clause that does an adverb’s job. Its verb is labelled advcl, and it normally starts with a subordinating conjunction labelled mark. The diagrams and exercises say adverb clause. We left because it rained. When the bell rang, everyone stood.

See: Adverb Clauses

Relative clause
The main kind of adjective clause: a clause modifying a noun, where the noun also has a job inside the clause. Labelled relcl; the relative pronoun may be absent. The violin that she inherited needs strings. The letter you sent arrived. — no pronoun at all.

See: Adjective Clauses

Adverbial objective
A noun phrase used adverbially, labelled npadvmod. It looks like an object, but it behaves like an adverb. The meeting ran three hours. We leave next Tuesday.

See: Adverbial Objectives & Retained Objects

Practice on a real sentence

This sentence has two prepositional phrases, so the prep and pobj buttons each show ×2. One phrase modifies the verb and the other modifies a noun: decide which is which before you click a head. If you finished this sentence on an earlier page, press Restart to practise it again.

Loading the practice sentence…